Skip to main content



Free ShippingFree Shipping on Orders $49 or more! View Details

Promo Codes & Deals

Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Posted by Lexi's Garage on Jan 23rd 2026

Lexi's Garage has nostalgic Halloween party supplies. Remember the Halloweens of past with fun nostalgic Halloween party supplies. Shop LexisGarage.com for all your nostalgic Halloween party supplies. Below are products perfect for bringing back old memories.

Nostalgic Halloween Cat Tablecloth | Party Decorations Nostalgic Halloween Cat Tablecloth, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Polyester
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 55" x 90.5"
Item: 110178
Nostalgic Tissue Spider Decoration | Party Decorations Nostalgic Halloween Tissue Spider Decoration, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 12" x 12.5"
Item: 110484
9 in Round Nostalgic Halloween Plates | Party Serveware 9" Round Nostalgic Halloween Plates (8 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Assorted styles - Sorry, no choice
Package Count: 8/Pkg
Size: 9"
Item: 110252
Ghost/Witch/Cat Garland Banner | Party Decorations Classic Ghost/Witch/Cat Jointed Garland Banner, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Jointed
Garland banner streamer
Printed on 2 sides
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 10" x 6 ft 11"
Item: 110563
Nostalgic Pumpkin/Cat Toothpicks | Party Serveware Nostalgic Halloween Pumpkin/Cat Toothpicks (50 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Assorted styles - Sorry, no choice
Package Count: 50/Pkg
Size: 3.5"
Item: 110454
Witch/Haunted House Door Cover | Party Decorations Classic Witch/Haunted House Door Cover, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Indoor & outdoor use
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 30" x 6 ft
Item: 110537
Jointed Halloween Dancer Cutouts | Party Decorations Classic Jointed Halloween Dancer Cutouts (2 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Jointed
Package Count: 2/Pkg
Size: 14" & 14.5"
Item: 110577
Nostalgic Halloween Yard Signs | Party Decorations Nostalgic Outdoor Halloween Yard Signs (6 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

6 Metal stakes included
Assembly required
Package Count: 6/Pkg
Size: 11.5"-12.25"
Item: 110654
Classic Pumpkin Face Paper Lantern | Party Decorations Classic Pumpkin Face Paper Lanterns (3 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Paper lanterns
Package Count: 3/Pkg
Size: 9.5"
Item: 110360
Jumbo Nostalgic Jointed Witch | Party Decorations Jumbo Nostalgic Jointed Halloween Witch, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Jointed
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 4 ft 9"
Item: 110470
Haunted House Table Centerpiece | Party Decorations Nostalgic Tissue Haunted House Table Centerpiece, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

6 Tombstones included
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 14.25"
Item: 110406
Halloween Party Decorations Kit | Party Decorations Classic Halloween Themed Party Decorations Kit (28 pcs/kit), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Halloween theme
Piece Count: 28
Item: 110508
Nostalgic Halloween Streamer | Party Decorations Nostalgic Halloween String Streamer, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Garland string banner streamer
Printed on 2 sides
Assembly required
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 8" x 6 ft
Item: 110268
Nostalgic Halloween Napkins | Party Serveware Nostalgic Halloween Napkins (16 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Assorted styles - Sorry, no choice
2-Ply
Package Count: 16/Pkg
Size: Approx 6.5" Square
Item: 110284
Nostalgic Moon/Witch Cutouts | Party Decorations Nostalgic Moon/Witch/Pumpkin Cutouts (4 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Printed on 2 sides
Package Count: 4/Pkg
Size: 9"
Item: 110415
Classic Jointed Cats Cutouts | Party Decorations Classic Jointed Halloween Cats Cutouts (4 pcs/pk), Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

Jointed
Package Count: 4/Pkg
Size: 19"-27"
Item: 110327
3-D Ghost/Coffin Centerpiece | Party Decorations Classic 3-D Ghost/Coffin Centerpiece, Nostalgic Halloween Party Supplies

3-D decoration
Assembly required
Package Count: 1/Pkg
Size: 12.75"
Item: 110625

© 2026 Lexi's Garage

!